Maguire Automotive

4.1 (677reviews)
66%
370 Elmira Rd,  Ithaca,  NY  14850

We are a full-service collision center with a large manufacture base, we are the preferred repair shop for Toyota Kia VW Audi and Volvo. We have the area's best body technicians with the quality you would expect from the Maguire Auto group.

Services
  • Free Estimates
  • Insurance Company Assistance
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Full Service Mechanical
  • Towing
  • Automotive Glass Replacement
  • Paintless Dent Repair
Payment Types
  • American Express
  • Discover Card
  • MasterCard
  • Visa
  • Cash
  • Check
  • Debit Card
Languages
  • English
Hours
Sun Closed
Mon 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Tue 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Wed 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Thu 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Fri 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Sat Closed
* Holiday hours may differ.
Volvo

Reviews (677)

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Very pleased with the work and the service.

Customer Service

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Great job

Customer Service

Pleasant and easy to deal with

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Thank you so much for repairing my car. Truly appreciate it

Customer Service

Your receptionist is very polite towards me.

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Everyone went above and beyond to help me through the process. I am especially thankful for Geselle as she was extremely personable and helpful

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Likely to Recommend

Have used Maguire for years both to buy and service my cars, even before it became Maguire.

Repair Quality

They estimated a week was needed to make the necessary repairs, but got them done in 3 days and handled the matter of a rental car (through Enterprise) smoothly. Great service.

Customer Service

All happened smoothly.

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Likely to Recommend

As a high volume production body shop where profit appears to be the focus, I can only recommend Maguire body shop as such for its customer service and convenience, not for quality of repair or maintaining OEM fit and finish.

Repair Quality

AC condenser is leaking, strong smell of antifreeze under hood after 1 week. Used headlight assemblies that have been polished and are already showing as hazed. severly corroded bolts reused instead of replaced. Paint quality not OEM, aftermarket bumper cover has seem lines not on OEM part. Grill badging not installed to OEM location. Overall a mid level quality high production shop repair with what seems like little care or attention to detail vs. profit.

Customer Service

Customer service was polite, efficient, and friendly to work with.

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Likely to Recommend

I will continue to buy Audis because of the level of service I have received.

Repair Quality

Excellent work - I cannot tell that the front end was replaced.

Customer Service

The customer service was fabulous. The wonderful lady that I interacted with could not have been more helpful. The young man who did the initial assessment was also very good - recommended that I leave the car rather than continue to drive it.

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

I found parts packaging left in my car when I retrieved it. Also my headlights were left on. It had difficulty starting and that’s how I noticed. I told the receptionist both of these things.

Customer Service

Taylor was a pleasure to talk with and very helpful, as were front desk reps

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

The team, John, Christina, Abbey, Andrea, Brian, at Maguire Subaru are great and do work as a team. They are professional, knowledgeable, helpful and followed CDC protocol.

Customer Service

Good customer service and follow up.

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Great job

Customer Service

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Satisfied, technician didn't take care of the dash light that was on due to the accident I brought my vehicle in from.

Customer Service

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Great job

Customer Service

A tiny nick was found afterwards. Not their fault. They jumped thru hoops to make it better.

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

They did a wonderful job!

Returned Clean

Likely to Recommend

Repair Quality

Customer Service

Returned Clean