Loading

Best Auto Body Shops near Middle Island, NY

Close filters
Sort and filters
RESET
Sort

Distance
Certifications
Ratings
  • 5.0
    998 reviews
    624 North Street, Manorville

    "Yes, I referred them to a friend or a colleague because they’re very kind and they give good customer service"

    "Yes, I referred them to a friend or a colleague because they’re very kind and they give good customer service"

    "Yes, I referred them to a friend or a colleague because they’re very kind and they give good customer service"

    "Yes, I referred them to a friend or a colleague because they’re very kind and they give good customer service"

    "Yes, I referred them to a friend or a colleague because they’re very kind and they give good customer service"

    "Yes, I referred them to a friend or a colleague because they’re very kind and they give good customer service"

  • 5.0
    552 reviews
    19 N Columbia St, Port Jefferson

    "On both occasions that I have used Portside the experience has been 10s across the board! Thank you."

    "On both occasions that I have used Portside the experience has been 10s across the board! Thank you."

    "On both occasions that I have used Portside the experience has been 10s across the board! Thank you."

    "On both occasions that I have used Portside the experience has been 10s across the board! Thank you."

    "On both occasions that I have used Portside the experience has been 10s across the board! Thank you."

    "On both occasions that I have used Portside the experience has been 10s across the board! Thank you."

  • 5.0
    282 reviews
    382 E Main St, Patchogue

    "Bona Fide Auto Collision was AMAZING! They went above and beyond from beginning to end. They made a process that could have taken a long time go so much quicker and easier for me. Their communication, professionalism, and attention to detail were outstanding. They made my car look absolutely beautiful and it drives better then it did before my accident! I am extremely happy with the work they did and truly appreciate everything they did to make the whole experience as stress-free as possible. I would highly recommend Bona Fide Auto Collision to anyone who needs collision repair. They really went above and beyond!"

    "Bona Fide Auto Collision was AMAZING! They went above and beyond from beginning to end. They made a process that could have taken a long time go so much quicker and easier for me. Their communication, professionalis..."

    "Bona Fide Auto Collision was AMAZING! They went above and beyond from beginning to end. They made a process that could have taken a long time go so much quicker and easier for me. Their..."

    "Bona Fide Auto Collision was AMAZING! They went above and beyond from beginning to end. They made a process that could have taken a long time go so much quicker and easier for me. Their communication, professionalism, and attention to detail were outstanding. They made my car look absolutely beautiful and it drives better then it did before my accident! I am extremely happy with the work they did and truly appreciate everything they did to make the whole experience as stress-free as possible. I would highly recommend Bona Fide Auto Collision to anyone who needs collision repair. They really went above and beyond!"

    "Bona Fide Auto Collision was AMAZING! They went above and beyond from beginning to end. They made a process that could have taken a long time go so much quicker and easier for me. Their..."

    "Bona Fide Auto Collision was AMAZING! They went above and beyond from beginning to end. They made a process that could have taken a long time go so much quicker and easier for me. Their communication, professionalism, and attentio..."

  • 5.0
    208 reviews
    10 New York Ave (Mailing), Sound Beach

    "Completely satisfied with service and employees . Job well done. Had other repairs done by Matt’s One Stop . No complaints here ."

    "Completely satisfied with service and employees . Job well done. Had other repairs done by Matt’s One Stop . No complaints here ."

    "Completely satisfied with service and employees . Job well done. Had other repairs done by Matt’s One Stop . No complaints here ."

    "Completely satisfied with service and employees . Job well done. Had other repairs done by Matt’s One Stop . No complaints here ."

    "Completely satisfied with service and employees . Job well done. Had other repairs done by Matt’s One Stop . No complaints here ."

    "Completely satisfied with service and employees . Job well done. Had other repairs done by Matt’s One Stop . No complaints here ."

  • 5.0
    143 reviews
    885 Sylvan Ave., Bayport

    "I received a call to pick up my car and it wasn’t satisfactory. Owen apologised and I would be called. Tiffany called that it was finished. My car looked amazing, thank you!! Hopefully, I will return one day to get some of the other dings, I’ve acquired over the years taken care of. Thanks again!"

    "I received a call to pick up my car and it wasn’t satisfactory. Owen apologised and I would be called. Tiffany called that it was finished. My car looked amazing, thank you!! Hopefully, I will return one day to ..."

    "I received a call to pick up my car and it wasn’t satisfactory. Owen apologised and I would be called. Tiffany called that it was finished. My car looked amazing, thank you!! Hopefu..."

    "I received a call to pick up my car and it wasn’t satisfactory. Owen apologised and I would be called. Tiffany called that it was finished. My car looked amazing, thank you!! Hopefully, I will return one day to get some of the other dings, I’ve acquired over the years taken care of. Thanks again!"

    "I received a call to pick up my car and it wasn’t satisfactory. Owen apologised and I would be called. Tiffany called that it was finished. My car looked amazing, thank you!! Hopefu..."

    "I received a call to pick up my car and it wasn’t satisfactory. Owen apologised and I would be called. Tiffany called that it was finished. My car looked amazing, thank you!! Hopefully, I will return one day to get some of the..."

  • 5.0
    52 reviews
    2164 Rt. 112, Medford

    "All people up front were so helpful. I greatly appreciated everything they did. I even brought them cookies. I highly recommend your business and will always bring vehicle to your establishment."

    "All people up front were so helpful. I greatly appreciated everything they did. I even brought them cookies. I highly recommend your business and will always bring vehicle to your establishment."

    "All people up front were so helpful. I greatly appreciated everything they did. I even brought them cookies. I highly recommend your business and will always bring vehicle to your esta..."

    "All people up front were so helpful. I greatly appreciated everything they did. I even brought them cookies. I highly recommend your business and will always bring vehicle to your establishment."

    "All people up front were so helpful. I greatly appreciated everything they did. I even brought them cookies. I highly recommend your business and will always bring vehicle to your esta..."

    "All people up front were so helpful. I greatly appreciated everything they did. I even brought them cookies. I highly recommend your business and will always bring vehicle to your establishment."

  • 4.9
    3,858 reviews
    3688 Horseblock Rd, Medford

    "Great service. Steve was amazing!! Rest of the staff was equally as helpful and great too. Very easy process."

    "Great service. Steve was amazing!! Rest of the staff was equally as helpful and great too. Very easy process."

    "Great service. Steve was amazing!! Rest of the staff was equally as helpful and great too. Very easy process."

    "Great service. Steve was amazing!! Rest of the staff was equally as helpful and great too. Very easy process."

    "Great service. Steve was amazing!! Rest of the staff was equally as helpful and great too. Very easy process."

    "Great service. Steve was amazing!! Rest of the staff was equally as helpful and great too. Very easy process."

  • 4.9
    1,978 reviews
    725 Route 25a, Rocky Point

    "Easy seamless repair. Communication is great with regular updates and status through the experience. Thanks Rocky Point NY Team"

    "Easy seamless repair. Communication is great with regular updates and status through the experience. Thanks Rocky Point NY Team"

    "Easy seamless repair. Communication is great with regular updates and status through the experience. Thanks Rocky Point NY Team"

    "Easy seamless repair. Communication is great with regular updates and status through the experience. Thanks Rocky Point NY Team"

    "Easy seamless repair. Communication is great with regular updates and status through the experience. Thanks Rocky Point NY Team"

    "Easy seamless repair. Communication is great with regular updates and status through the experience. Thanks Rocky Point NY Team"

  • 4.9
    797 reviews
    15 Railroad Ave, Port Jefferson Station

    "Great communication through email updates and phone calls. The emails shared the expected completion date."

    "Great communication through email updates and phone calls. The emails shared the expected completion date."

    "Great communication through email updates and phone calls. The emails shared the expected completion date."

    "Great communication through email updates and phone calls. The emails shared the expected completion date."

    "Great communication through email updates and phone calls. The emails shared the expected completion date."

    "Great communication through email updates and phone calls. The emails shared the expected completion date."

  • 4.9
    683 reviews
    26 Texaco Ave, Port Jefferson

    "Thanks for completing the job so quickly. We were able to avoid renting a car because of your efficiency. The car’s back end looked like brand new. Thanks for the quality work and the good customer service."

    "Thanks for completing the job so quickly. We were able to avoid renting a car because of your efficiency. The car’s back end looked like brand new. Thanks for the quality work and the good customer service."

    "Thanks for completing the job so quickly. We were able to avoid renting a car because of your efficiency. The car’s back end looked like brand new. Thanks for the quality work and the g..."

    "Thanks for completing the job so quickly. We were able to avoid renting a car because of your efficiency. The car’s back end looked like brand new. Thanks for the quality work and the good customer service."

    "Thanks for completing the job so quickly. We were able to avoid renting a car because of your efficiency. The car’s back end looked like brand new. Thanks for the quality work and the g..."

    "Thanks for completing the job so quickly. We were able to avoid renting a car because of your efficiency. The car’s back end looked like brand new. Thanks for the quality work and the good customer service."

  • 4.9
    574 reviews
    1791 Montauk Hwy, Bellport

    "Absolutely the best auto repair shop. And while I had high expectations for the exterior work (give them 10 stars), I never expected the interior detailing. My car never looked so good, both inside and out. Highly recommend them without any reservations!!!"

    "Absolutely the best auto repair shop. And while I had high expectations for the exterior work (give them 10 stars), I never expected the interior detailing. My car never looked so good, both inside and out. Highly r..."

    "Absolutely the best auto repair shop. And while I had high expectations for the exterior work (give them 10 stars), I never expected the interior detailing. My car never looked so good,..."

    "Absolutely the best auto repair shop. And while I had high expectations for the exterior work (give them 10 stars), I never expected the interior detailing. My car never looked so good, both inside and out. Highly recommend them without any reservations!!!"

    "Absolutely the best auto repair shop. And while I had high expectations for the exterior work (give them 10 stars), I never expected the interior detailing. My car never looked so good,..."

    "Absolutely the best auto repair shop. And while I had high expectations for the exterior work (give them 10 stars), I never expected the interior detailing. My car never looked so good, both inside and out. Highly recommend them w..."

  • 4.9
    504 reviews
    91 Gnarled Hollow Rd, East Setauket

    "Staff were kind, knowledgeable, and professional. Repairs were completed in good time, and there was regular communication through their online system. Never fun to go through these issues, but you all helped make this as easy and seamless of a process as it could have been (along with the seamless connection to the insurance company and rental car agency). Thank you!"

    "Staff were kind, knowledgeable, and professional. Repairs were completed in good time, and there was regular communication through their online system. Never fun to go through these issues, but you all helped make t..."

    "Staff were kind, knowledgeable, and professional. Repairs were completed in good time, and there was regular communication through their online system. Never fun to go through these iss..."

    "Staff were kind, knowledgeable, and professional. Repairs were completed in good time, and there was regular communication through their online system. Never fun to go through these issues, but you all helped make this as easy and seamless of a process as it could have been (along with the seamless connection to the insurance company and rental car agency). Thank you!"

    "Staff were kind, knowledgeable, and professional. Repairs were completed in good time, and there was regular communication through their online system. Never fun to go through these iss..."

    "Staff were kind, knowledgeable, and professional. Repairs were completed in good time, and there was regular communication through their online system. Never fun to go through these issues, but you all helped make this as easy and..."

  • 4.9
    433 reviews
    70 Comsewogue Road, East Setauket
  • 4.9
    430 reviews
    135 Hallock Avenue, Port Jefferson Station

    "Had a great experience. The staff was polite and understanding. They made the process easy and the workmanship was outstanding. They even delivered the car ahead of schedule. I would definitely recommend them."

    "Had a great experience. The staff was polite and understanding. They made the process easy and the workmanship was outstanding. They even delivered the car ahead of schedule. I would definitely recommend them."

    "Had a great experience. The staff was polite and understanding. They made the process easy and the workmanship was outstanding. They even delivered the car ahead of schedule. I would de..."

    "Had a great experience. The staff was polite and understanding. They made the process easy and the workmanship was outstanding. They even delivered the car ahead of schedule. I would definitely recommend them."

    "Had a great experience. The staff was polite and understanding. They made the process easy and the workmanship was outstanding. They even delivered the car ahead of schedule. I would de..."

    "Had a great experience. The staff was polite and understanding. They made the process easy and the workmanship was outstanding. They even delivered the car ahead of schedule. I would definitely recommend them."

  • 4.9
    182 reviews
    2864b Route 112, Medford

    "My car came out great and the customer service was excellent. I was updated on the progrsss every step of the way."

    "My car came out great and the customer service was excellent. I was updated on the progrsss every step of the way."

    "My car came out great and the customer service was excellent. I was updated on the progrsss every step of the way."

    "My car came out great and the customer service was excellent. I was updated on the progrsss every step of the way."

    "My car came out great and the customer service was excellent. I was updated on the progrsss every step of the way."

    "My car came out great and the customer service was excellent. I was updated on the progrsss every step of the way."

  • 4.9
    176 reviews
    3350 Nesconset Hwy, East Setauket

    "I had a great experience with Setauket auto body. Everyone was extremely helpful and nice. The lobby was unbelievable amazing, decor was top notch. But even better was my car… it was fixed and looks brand new! Thank you!"

    "I had a great experience with Setauket auto body. Everyone was extremely helpful and nice. The lobby was unbelievable amazing, decor was top notch. But even better was my car… it was fixed and looks brand new! Thank..."

    "I had a great experience with Setauket auto body. Everyone was extremely helpful and nice. The lobby was unbelievable amazing, decor was top notch. But even better was my car… it was fi..."

    "I had a great experience with Setauket auto body. Everyone was extremely helpful and nice. The lobby was unbelievable amazing, decor was top notch. But even better was my car… it was fixed and looks brand new! Thank you!"

    "I had a great experience with Setauket auto body. Everyone was extremely helpful and nice. The lobby was unbelievable amazing, decor was top notch. But even better was my car… it was fi..."

    "I had a great experience with Setauket auto body. Everyone was extremely helpful and nice. The lobby was unbelievable amazing, decor was top notch. But even better was my car… it was fixed and looks brand new! Thank you!"

  • 4.9
    123 reviews
    14 Industrial Rd, Port Jefferson Station

    "I got lucky, I walked away from a terrible car accident. Then I was lucky again to have Collision Works to repair my car. Frank and his team communicated on each step. My car is perfectly restored. Highly recommend this team! 10! 5 Star!"

    "I got lucky, I walked away from a terrible car accident. Then I was lucky again to have Collision Works to repair my car. Frank and his team communicated on each step. My car is perfectly restored. Highly recommend ..."

    "I got lucky, I walked away from a terrible car accident. Then I was lucky again to have Collision Works to repair my car. Frank and his team communicated on each step. My car is perfect..."

    "I got lucky, I walked away from a terrible car accident. Then I was lucky again to have Collision Works to repair my car. Frank and his team communicated on each step. My car is perfectly restored. Highly recommend this team! 10! 5 Star!"

    "I got lucky, I walked away from a terrible car accident. Then I was lucky again to have Collision Works to repair my car. Frank and his team communicated on each step. My car is perfect..."

    "I got lucky, I walked away from a terrible car accident. Then I was lucky again to have Collision Works to repair my car. Frank and his team communicated on each step. My car is perfectly restored. Highly recommend this team! 10! ..."

  • 4.8
    3,014 reviews
    225 Medford Ave, Patchogue

    "Car looks good. The only issue I had was being told it would be done by a certain date. It wasn’t done until 4 days later."

    "Car looks good. The only issue I had was being told it would be done by a certain date. It wasn’t done until 4 days later."

    "Car looks good. The only issue I had was being told it would be done by a certain date. It wasn’t done until 4 days later."

    "Car looks good. The only issue I had was being told it would be done by a certain date. It wasn’t done until 4 days later."

    "Car looks good. The only issue I had was being told it would be done by a certain date. It wasn’t done until 4 days later."

    "Car looks good. The only issue I had was being told it would be done by a certain date. It wasn’t done until 4 days later."

  • 4.8
    1,669 reviews
    30 Chestnut St, Mount Sinai

    "SCOTTSMANS does great work. Samantha (SAM) at the front office always courteous and informing. Relative to what is going on with our vehicle"

    "SCOTTSMANS does great work. Samantha (SAM) at the front office always courteous and informing. Relative to what is going on with our vehicle"

    "SCOTTSMANS does great work. Samantha (SAM) at the front office always courteous and informing. Relative to what is going on with our vehicle"

    "SCOTTSMANS does great work. Samantha (SAM) at the front office always courteous and informing. Relative to what is going on with our vehicle"

    "SCOTTSMANS does great work. Samantha (SAM) at the front office always courteous and informing. Relative to what is going on with our vehicle"

    "SCOTTSMANS does great work. Samantha (SAM) at the front office always courteous and informing. Relative to what is going on with our vehicle"

  • 4.8
    186 reviews
    802b Middle Country Rd, Selden

    "Working with Chris was such a great experience. The job they did was amazing, quick and was always kept updated on when my was would be ready. Highly recommend Nicks Auto Body."

    "Working with Chris was such a great experience. The job they did was amazing, quick and was always kept updated on when my was would be ready. Highly recommend Nicks Auto Body."

    "Working with Chris was such a great experience. The job they did was amazing, quick and was always kept updated on when my was would be ready. Highly recommend Nicks Auto Body."

    "Working with Chris was such a great experience. The job they did was amazing, quick and was always kept updated on when my was would be ready. Highly recommend Nicks Auto Body."

    "Working with Chris was such a great experience. The job they did was amazing, quick and was always kept updated on when my was would be ready. Highly recommend Nicks Auto Body."

    "Working with Chris was such a great experience. The job they did was amazing, quick and was always kept updated on when my was would be ready. Highly recommend Nicks Auto Body."

  • 4.8
    62 reviews
    2661 Middle Country Rd., Centereach

    "Bruce and team got my car done perfectly set up rental car and got it done ahead of time. Professional all around. Highly recommend"

    "Bruce and team got my car done perfectly set up rental car and got it done ahead of time. Professional all around. Highly recommend"

    "Bruce and team got my car done perfectly set up rental car and got it done ahead of time. Professional all around. Highly recommend"

    "Bruce and team got my car done perfectly set up rental car and got it done ahead of time. Professional all around. Highly recommend"

    "Bruce and team got my car done perfectly set up rental car and got it done ahead of time. Professional all around. Highly recommend"

    "Bruce and team got my car done perfectly set up rental car and got it done ahead of time. Professional all around. Highly recommend"

  • 4.7
    266 reviews
    23 HORSEBLOCK ROAD, Centereach

    "The work done on my SUV was completed quickly and better than new. All the staff is friendly and courteous. I have and will recommend Scottsmans for any friends repair needs."

    "The work done on my SUV was completed quickly and better than new. All the staff is friendly and courteous. I have and will recommend Scottsmans for any friends repair needs."

    "The work done on my SUV was completed quickly and better than new. All the staff is friendly and courteous. I have and will recommend Scottsmans for any friends repair needs."

    "The work done on my SUV was completed quickly and better than new. All the staff is friendly and courteous. I have and will recommend Scottsmans for any friends repair needs."

    "The work done on my SUV was completed quickly and better than new. All the staff is friendly and courteous. I have and will recommend Scottsmans for any friends repair needs."

    "The work done on my SUV was completed quickly and better than new. All the staff is friendly and courteous. I have and will recommend Scottsmans for any friends repair needs."

  • 5.0
    1 review
    465 Ny-25a, Mt Sinai
  • no rating
    1,237 reviews
    ., Centereach

    "Very accommodating.Addressed minor issues with professionalism & Respect! A pleasure to do business with. This is the third vehicle over more than 10 years & if need be I will go back again!"

    "Very accommodating.Addressed minor issues with professionalism & Respect! A pleasure to do business with. This is the third vehicle over more than 10 years & if need be I will go back again!"

    "Very accommodating.Addressed minor issues with professionalism & Respect! A pleasure to do business with. This is the third vehicle over more than 10 years & if need be I will go back a..."

    "Very accommodating.Addressed minor issues with professionalism & Respect! A pleasure to do business with. This is the third vehicle over more than 10 years & if need be I will go back again!"

    "Very accommodating.Addressed minor issues with professionalism & Respect! A pleasure to do business with. This is the third vehicle over more than 10 years & if need be I will go back a..."

    "Very accommodating.Addressed minor issues with professionalism & Respect! A pleasure to do business with. This is the third vehicle over more than 10 years & if need be I will go back again!"

  • no rating
    31 reviews
    2179 Route 112, Medford

    "Chris was great. He explained everything that needed to be done and had my car ready earlier so that I can pick it up when I needed to"

    "Chris was great. He explained everything that needed to be done and had my car ready earlier so that I can pick it up when I needed to"

    "Chris was great. He explained everything that needed to be done and had my car ready earlier so that I can pick it up when I needed to"

    "Chris was great. He explained everything that needed to be done and had my car ready earlier so that I can pick it up when I needed to"

    "Chris was great. He explained everything that needed to be done and had my car ready earlier so that I can pick it up when I needed to"

    "Chris was great. He explained everything that needed to be done and had my car ready earlier so that I can pick it up when I needed to"

  • no rating
    8 reviews
    1272 Montauk Hwy., Mastic
  • no rating
    148 Middle Country Rd., Middle Island
  • no rating
    44 Middle Country Road, Middle Island
  • no rating
    976 Route 25a, Miller Place

    "Was handled professionally. With friendly discussions and a completed job I’m very pleased with the results !"

    "Was handled professionally. With friendly discussions and a completed job I’m very pleased with the results !"

    "Was handled professionally. With friendly discussions and a completed job I’m very pleased with the results !"

    "Was handled professionally. With friendly discussions and a completed job I’m very pleased with the results !"

    "Was handled professionally. With friendly discussions and a completed job I’m very pleased with the results !"

    "Was handled professionally. With friendly discussions and a completed job I’m very pleased with the results !"

  • no rating
    1581 Route 112, Port Jefferson Station
  • no rating
    186 Waverly Ave, Patchogue
  • no rating
    2019 Route 112, Medford
  • no rating
    50-F Rocky Point Yaphank Rd, Rocky Point
  • no rating
    781 Route 25 A, Rocky Point
  • no rating
    1367 Middle Country Rd, Centereach
  • no rating
    1419 Montauk Hwy, East Patchogue
  • no rating
    695 Waverly Ave., Holtsville
  • no rating
    1384 Middle Country Rd, Centereach
  • no rating
    1546 Rocky Point Rd, Middle Island
  • no rating
    28 Tyler Street, Rocky Point

Auto Body Shops near Middle Island, NY

Carwise has an auto body shop network of over 22,000 auto body shops nationwide, and we are adding more auto body shops everyday.

Carwise can help you find an auto body shop near Middle Island, NY as well as track your vehicle's repair status, see photos of an auto body shop repair in progress or connect with the auto body shop directly.